Opens in a new tab
Golf content marketing scene with golf clubs and branding.
Back to Resources

The Year-End Review Most Operators Never Run

Author
Colby Johannson
Date
October 12, 2026
Read Time
6 min

The season ends and the planning begins.

New budget. New social calendar. Maybe a new campaign, a new agency, a new platform to try. The work of figuring out 2027 starts almost immediately after the last round of 2026.

There’s just one problem: most operators skip the step that should come first.

Before you decide where to spend, you need to know what actually worked. Not what felt like it worked. Not what the ad platform told you worked. What actually moved bookings, brought new golfers through the door, and built the kind of awareness that compounded over time.

Most courses don’t know. They have a rough sense. They remember which campaigns got approved and which got pushback. They have a gut feeling about Instagram.

That’s not a review. That’s a vibe.

Here are five questions worth answering honestly before you commit a dollar to next year.


1. Where did your bookings actually come from — not impressions, bookings?

This is the first question and the one most operators can’t answer cleanly.

You know where you spent money. You probably don’t know, with precision, where the bookings came from. And those two things are often very different.

The most common version of this: an operator is running Google Ads, Meta ads, and email. The assumption is that Google and Meta are doing the heavy lifting because that’s where the budget went. The actual data shows that email drove 40% of conversions, direct search drove another 30%, and paid channels combined drove less than the organic channels that cost almost nothing.

Pull your booking data by source. Cross-reference it with your channel spend. The gap between where you spent and where bookings originated is the most important number you’ll look at all year — and it’s the one that most directly tells you where to reallocate in 2027.


2. What did it actually cost you to bring in a new golfer?

Not a returning guest. Not someone who’s played your course ten times. A net new golfer who hadn’t been before.

Take your total marketing spend for the year. Divide it by the number of genuinely new golfers you acquired. That’s your cost per new customer.

Most operators have never calculated this number. When they do, it’s usually surprising — and not in a good way.

This number tells you several things at once: whether your acquisition channels are efficient, whether you’re over-investing in retention at the expense of growth, and whether the lifetime value of a new golfer justifies what you’re spending to get them. If you’re spending $200 to acquire a golfer who spends $150 and never comes back, you have a different problem than if you’re spending $200 to acquire a golfer who spends $900 over three seasons.

You can’t make smart decisions about 2027 budget without knowing this number for 2026.


3. What percentage of your rounds were from repeat guests versus new golfers?

This is the ratio that tells you whether your business is growing or just holding.

A course running at 85% repeat business has a loyalty problem masquerading as stability. That repeat base will age and attrit, and the pipeline to replace them is thin. A course running at 85% new golfers has the opposite problem — high acquisition costs, no loyalty flywheel, and word of mouth that isn’t compounding.

The healthy middle looks different for every course depending on the market, the product, and the price point. But you need to know where you actually sit before you can decide whether 2027 calls for a growth campaign, a retention play, or something in between.

Most operators assume they know this number. Most are wrong when they look at the actual data.


4. Which of your best channels cost you the least?

This question reframes the conversation from spend to return.

Look at your top three performing channels from a booking-conversion standpoint. Now look at what each one cost you to operate. The channels that drive results with low direct cost — organic search, email to an existing list, word of mouth referrals, earned media coverage — are the channels you should be investing time and infrastructure into, not just dollars.

The channels that require constant spend to stay active and go quiet the moment you pause the budget are the channels to scrutinize hardest going into 2027. They’re not necessarily wrong to run, but they should be understood for what they are: rented attention, not owned.

The operators who build durable marketing over time understand which channels compound and which ones don’t. This question helps you see the difference clearly.


5. If you had to cut one channel completely, which would it be — and have you looked at why?

This is the forcing function question, and it’s the most honest one on the list.

Every operator has a channel they keep running out of inertia. It’s never been clearly effective, but it’s also never been clearly ineffective — and cutting it would require someone to make a call and own the decision. So it persists, consuming budget and time that could go somewhere else.

Ask yourself which channel you’d eliminate first if you had no choice. The answer is usually the channel you already know isn’t working, and the fact that you haven’t cut it already is telling you something about how your marketing decisions actually get made.

This isn’t a case against taking risks or trying new things. It’s a case against running the same mediocre channel for the third consecutive year because nobody wanted to be the one to stop it.

Cut it. Move the budget. Find out if you were right.


The Goal Isn’t a Perfect Audit

You’re not going to get clean answers to all five of these. Attribution is messy, data has gaps, and some channels are genuinely hard to measure with precision.

That’s fine. The goal isn’t a perfect audit — it’s an honest one.

The operators who grow year over year aren’t the ones with the most sophisticated analytics stack. They’re the ones who ask hard questions at the end of each season, sit with the uncomfortable answers, and let those answers drive the plan.

The ones who skip this step come back in March wondering why the same spend is producing the same results.

Before you plan 2027, run the review. It takes an afternoon. It’s the most valuable afternoon of your off-season.

Operators who get it move early.
The rest play catch-up.

LET’S TALK

Operators who get it move early.
The rest play catch-up.

LET’S TALK
Most Golf Marketing
Is Forgettable.
This Email Isn’t.
2,000+ GMs, Owners, and Marketing Managers read this email every month. You should too.
One monthly email packed with what's working, what's trending, and real case studies.
Most Golf Marketing
Is Forgettable.
This Email Isn’t.
2,000+ GMs, Owners, and Marketing Managers read this email every month. You should too.
One monthly email packed with what's working, what's trending, and real case studies.